Band Saw for Resaw Purposes

  • November 16, 2024 10:14 AM
    Message # 13431485

    I've recently joined EMGW as a member; my primary interest is wood carving but am also interested in increasing my general woodworking skills.

    In the near term, I would like to begin resawing rough hewn wood. To that end, I'd like to acquire an appropriate band saw, and would appreciate any recommendations regarding minimum specs (e.g., dimensions, hp, speed, speed, cutting capacity, etc). I'm not building houses or furniture; I'm a hobbyist and I'm primarily interested in turning nominal lumber into material that can then be carved for various projects I work on. I have appropriate hand planes already to accomplish that that purpose. I think I should be looking for a stationary saw rather than a bench top. I'm very open to acquiring a good used piece of equipment, but will also consider new.

    Thanks for any suggestions the membership can offer me.  

  • November 16, 2024 10:32 AM
    Reply # 13431493 on 13431485

    Welcome to the guild, Mark. The answer to your question is dependent on several factors.

    1. Size of board - height of cut

    2. Green wood vs kiln dry

    3. Hardwood or Softwood

    4.  Shop space available 

    5. Your propensity to collect tools


    My situation is that I have two bandsaws. A 1948 Craftsman 12” BS with a blade averaging 1/8”-1/4” for primarily small cuts and curves and a 1938 Craftsman 16” BS with a 3/4” 3 tpi (teeth per inch) blade for straight cuts and resawing. I can cut up to a 10” piece of hardwood (very slowly) on the saw.

    As for your shop a good starter would be a Rikon 10” with a 3/8” tip blade that probably could do up to 6” cuts. From there you could go up to a 12”/14” Jet, Laguna or Powermatic that can cut up to 8” boards. Of course, if your patient and have an affinity for old tools the options expand exponentially.


    are you cutting hardwood or softwood, green or kiln dry? What is your preferable cut size?


    I’ll let others expound on my suggestions.

  • November 17, 2024 6:18 AM
    Reply # 13431669 on 13431485
    Anonymous

    The best band saws on the market now are the Rikon 14 inch and Laguna 14 inch. You could go bigger, I had room for an Grizzly 18 inch and not sorry I did. Grizzly is also as good a quality product as the Rikon and Laguna. Only downside is that Grizzly is internet sales only in this area.

    I work part time at Woodcraft in Woburn, we carry the Rikon, Laguna, Jet, and Powermatic, but have a hard time getting inventory from Jet and Powermatic, they're always on back order. 

    With a 14 inch or bigger size band saw you will have the ability to us 3/4" to 1" blades that make resawing easier. Smaller band saws are limited to 1/2" blades that maybe good for resawing softwoods, and hardwoods a real challenge.

    Good luck on your search.

    Jim Allen

  • November 17, 2024 6:54 AM
    Reply # 13431674 on 13431485
    I have a love hate relationship with bandsaws.  I’ve seen the same brand and model of band saw give wildly different results. 


    im generally down with the laguna/rikon recommendations. Grizzly I’ve used and had good results with. My caution about grizzly is step out of the hobbyist class and into the low end professional class. 

    both rikon and grizzly have very good customer service. Rikon is based locally and if the part is in the USA it’s easy to get.  Laguna and powermatic are problematic about parts and customer service. 

    I’m generally a buy it once person and try to get stationary machinery.  Ther is something to be said for getting a bench top and keeping a small blade on it as well as a stationary machine.  In my work I don’t use a bandsaw a lot.  Pretty much only for things a table saw is the wrong choice. 

    Last modified: November 17, 2024 7:02 AM | Dana Farmer
  • November 17, 2024 7:29 AM
    Reply # 13431676 on 13431485
    John LeJeune (Administrator)

    I've been very happy with my Laguna 14BX.  It was recommended to me by Rolly Johnson from Fine Woodworking.  He has done band saw reviews and wrote a book on band saws.  Please get the 14BX over the 14-Twelve if it is in your budget.  The full cabinet and foot break with switch is a game changer.

  • November 17, 2024 8:25 AM
    Reply # 13431680 on 13431485

    Hi Mark.  I have a 14” Harvey    It has 13” resaw capacity and 3 horsepower   I’ve been very happy with it and it’s about the same price as the others mentioned in the thread. I have a 3/4” carbide blade on it currently. If you would like to try it out, bring a sample of what you want to cut and come. On by.  

  • November 17, 2024 10:19 AM
    Reply # 13431696 on 13431485

    Thanks to you all for your valuable and rapid responses. I've got adequate shop space (including a fixed bench and portable Dewalt table saw and Dewalt compound miter saw) for a stationary band saw set up. This will be a jack-of-all-trades piece of equipment for me in terms of resaw capability, so looking to handle up to 12" or so material width; hardwood and softwood, with green and kiln dried. As much as possible, I don't want to limit my choice of work material by being too narrow with my choices of equipment. 

    Last modified: November 17, 2024 6:33 PM | Mark Curran

Eastern Massachusetts Guild of Woodworkers. Copyright © 2024  Privacy and Cookie Policy

Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software