How strong is hide glue? Strong enough for a seat?
I took top of the donor desk I'm using for the project to a FIG meeting. And consensus was 4/4 quarter sawn tight grain white oak. Since the plan calls for 6/4 seat, I'd considered stacking the halves of the top then planing down to 6/4. But even at 4/4 it's pretty hefty. Someone also pointed that out, as well as that the seats of all of the stick chairs in the house we were at were about 4/4.
All good, but now it occurs to me the top is actually multiple boards - is the existing seam likely to be solid enough??? Looks and feels tight, and there's what is probably hide glue on the mortise & tenons, so probably hide glue on the tongue & groove seam. That enough? This design doesn't have stretchers, so a bit more torque on the seat.
As a side note, the carrier frame for the desk top has a corrugated fastener at each corner, so between that and the hide glue means 40's or 50's.